Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said US negotiators asked whether Ukraine would withdraw from the Donbas in exchange for NATO membership, the first time such a linkage has been raised in the war's diplomatic track [1][3][31]. Zelensky stated that Ukraine would not cede or legally recognize occupied territory and that any confirmed security package — comprising NATO and EU guarantees, a funded army, and reconstruction money — would go to a national referendum [17][23][34]. "If the American side confirms precisely this to us, together with other NATO partners, then I will ask our Ukrainian society what it thinks: do we accept it or not? I have no right to make that decision on my own," Zelensky said [17].

NATO deputy commander John Stringer said territorial concessions are exclusively Kyiv's decision [38]. Ukrainian polling shows 60 percent oppose trading land for NATO membership and 79 percent distrust US security guarantees [49]. Zelensky said Washington floated Articles 4 and 5 guarantees but ruled out deploying US soldiers on Ukrainian soil [17]. He rejected a Russian-proposed temporary ceasefire in Kostiantynivka, calling it a ruse to force Ukrainian withdrawal and allow Russian forces to seize the city [16]. The diplomacy ran alongside continued strikes: Russian attacks injured at least 22 people in Zaporizhzhia and killed one in Pavlohrad, and Russia's Defence Ministry reported capturing Tersianka in Zaporizhzhia and striking Ukrainian energy infrastructure, while Ukraine's General Staff reported hitting an oil terminal in Russia's Samara region [8][24].

Russian officials presented a document dated 10 November reviving the December 2021 ultimatum: NATO withdrawal to pre-1997 positions, an end to expansion, limits on NATO forces in Poland and the Baltics, no Western arms for Kyiv, limits on British and French nuclear protection, and curbs on alliance activity in Eastern Europe, the South Caucasus, and Central Asia, with further demands touching Moldova's state structure and post-war Ukrainian participation in Western defense [28][35][47][14]. Finland rejected the reported demand that NATO troops leave Poland and the Baltics [43]. Russian chief negotiator Vladimir Medinsky called for a "new, modern Yalta" to reorganize European security and said Russia had received no concrete peace proposal from European countries [7][32]. Russian officials at the Abu Dhabi talks invoked the Cold War and Warsaw Pact as models of separate spheres of influence that reduced conflict risk [28][35].

The Kremlin said it will not agree to a ceasefire until a final peace deal includes Ukraine ceding the remaining Donbas and Crimea [31]. Medinsky said Russia will capture all of its claimed land and rejected any territorial exchanges [39]. The Institute for the Study of War reported that Russian officials falsely told US and Ukrainian delegations in Abu Dhabi that Russian forces control half of the Ukrainian-held part of Donbas [39].

US officials stressed that many ideas are still being discussed, no final deal exists without both parties' consent, and confidentiality must be maintained [31][7]. US special envoy Jared Kushner said "several new ideas emerged from the discussions and are now being explored" and said the US is "determined to continue the hard work, maintain the confidentiality necessary for sensitive negotiations, and find a pathway to end this horrible war" [7]. French analyst Ulrich Bounat called the reported US shift a radical turning point but considered Russian acceptance extremely unlikely and suggested Zelensky may be using strategic disclosure to force Washington to clarify its position [22]. Washington has not officially confirmed the linkage [45][36]. Zelensky himself said no concrete proposal has been tabled — the linkage was raised as an open question rather than a formal offer [19][22][23].

EU leaders assembled a negotiating team of France, Germany, Italy, Poland, the UK, and EU institutions in Dublin [12][32]. European Council President António Costa said Europe must speak with one clear and united voice in all discussions shaping Ukraine's future and continental security [12]. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said Europe's inclusion in peace talks is self-explanatory [12]. Kushner said both sides agreed to expand the next round to include European partners but said identifying one European spokesperson "would be a bigger achievement than getting the Russians to include them in the negotiations" [5][12].

EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas warned that Russia's push to renegotiate European security architecture is a trap designed to divert attention from the absent ceasefire [6][12]. "First we need a ceasefire. If we start to talk about what Russia is asking regarding the security architecture, we actually walk into the traps that Russia is setting us," Kallas said [32]. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz dismissed the need to discuss the architecture because it already exists [4][7]. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney said Europe and NATO, not Russia or revised Minsk agreements, will determine the continent's security [26]. Estonian Prime Minister Kristen Michal called Russia's push to revise Europe's security system "psychological games" [26].

French President Emmanuel Macron warned that rationing aid to Ukraine amounts to forcing an unjust peace that is a recipe for another war [7][9]. Spanish and Argentine commentators argued that a weakened White House may trade sweeping Ukrainian concessions for a quick settlement and that Europe cannot delegate Ukraine's future to Vladimir Putin or Donald Trump [10][15]. Trump said it was "time for Ukraine to get a new president" and called for fresh elections after asking Kyiv to pause strikes on Russian oil facilities [31].

Analysts treated the coming Trump-Xi-Putin trilateral at APEC in Shenzhen as performative photo-op diplomacy that cannot end the war [29]. Beijing reportedly resists hosting any Ukraine deal, with Xi Jinping telling German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier the war is Europe's to negotiate [41]. Chinese officials rejected trilateral nuclear disarmament talks as "neither fair, reasonable nor realistic" [29]. US-based analysts argued Xi holds unique leverage over Putin through trade and dual-use supplies but has chosen not to use it [42].

Gulf economic analysis framed the talks as an energy, trade, and frozen-asset question, with war compensation likely resolved through package deals rather than direct Russian obligations [50]. A former Russian diplomat said the war spurred a pivot of Russian economic ties toward Asia that would not reverse to previous levels [50]. Professor Alan Kafrouni of Hamilton College cited Russian diesel and fertilizer supplies and the effect of Black Sea attacks on grain exports and food prices for import-dependent economies [50][44].

The next round of talks is expected to include European partners, though Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said a decision on European participation depends on understanding Europe's true intentions [5][18]. A prisoner exchange involving 1,200 to 1,300 people from each side is under discussion [30]. The Trump-Xi-Putin trilateral is scheduled for November 18-19 in Shenzhen [29].